Environmental gradients drive physiological variation in Hawaiian corals

To evaluate potential coral adaptive mechanisms, we investigated physiological traits (biomass, lipid, protein, chlorophyll, and isotopic proxies for trophic strategy) in eight Hawaiian corals species along an environmental gradient of significant wave height, sea surface temperature, and seawater chlorophyll a concentration around the island of O‘ahu, Hawai‘i. We used the amount of physiological variation expressed in corals, and the proportion of this variation that could be explained by environmental variables, to construct hypotheses about the relative capacity for each species to adapt or acclimatize to differing conditions. Genus-level analyses indicated that Montipora and Pocillopora phenotypes are influenced more strongly by the environment than Porites corals. Species-level analyses revealed that Montipora capitata and Pocillopora acuta have the widest physiological niche boundaries, whereas Porites evermanni and Pocillopora meandrina are more physiologically restricted. Correlations between individual traits and the environmental gradient provided insight into potential adaptive mechanisms employed by each species that allow them to persist in reefs such as those within Kāne’ohe Bay, where water flow is lowest, and temperature, acidity, and nutrient concentrations are highest relative to other reefs around O‘ahu. Potential adaptive mechanisms included (a) increased surface-area-to-volume ratios to facilitate higher material flux across the diffusive boundary layer and/or to maximize light harvesting (M. capitata and P. acuta), (b) strategic investment of metabolic energy toward energy reserves (Montipora and Pocillopora), (c) changes in protein management likely via differential expression and function (Porites), and d) increased chlorophyll concentration per Symbiodiniaceae cell to maximize photosynthesis (Porites compressa). Comparison of our results with established patterns in the relative abundance of these species around O‘ahu suggests that species with wide physiological niche boundaries like M. capitata and M. flabellata might be expected to do better under predicted future ocean conditions and outcompete species such as P. evermanni and P. meandrina, making them potential candidates for coral conservation efforts.