Can whiskers grow on bulk lead-free solder?

Many possible mechanisms for whisker growth exist, each possible in various scenarios investigated in the literature. This contribution addresses the importance of residual mechanical stress in a solder alloy for providing some of the energy necessary to drive possible whisker growth. We investigate the indentations made on bulk lead-free solder (Sn3.5Ag) to introduce various levels of residual energy associated with localized residual stresses. We confirm that localized residual stresses, in the absence of a thin-film geometry, significant oxide thickness, and interdiffusional stresses from intermetallic Cu-Sn compounds, do not result in the formation of whiskers in bulk Sn3.5Ag. Thus, the combination of stresses associated with thin films (either thermal misfit, plating, or chemical) and the oxidation of Sn at the surface is likely required for continuous whisker growth.