Points of contention and convergence

In this portion of the clinical exchange, Drs. Kathleen Chard and Thomas Widiger, Joel Paris, Kenneth Silk, Amy Wagner, and Jeffrey Young discuss areas of agreement and disagreement about their concepts of the case, as described in their separate articles in this issue of the journal, of the patient with traits of borderline personality disorder described in "Restitution 101." Issues of diagnosis, phenomenology, case formulation, and treatment models and techniques are compared with an eye toward integrating the various viewpoints.